Five jewelers' return and resize terms, read from their own pages on 23 October 2026: windows run from 10 to 60 days, and the clock starts at three different moments.
Maison Assay finding
On 23 October 2026, five jewelers' own pages gave return windows from 10 days (Whiteflash, lab-grown stones) to 60 days (Clean Origin), and Ritani's own pages state two different free-resize windows: 30 days on its engagement ring page and one year in its FAQ.
It depends on which clause you care about, because no one policy wins on all of them. Clean Origin gives the longest return window here, 60 days. Brilliant Earth and Ritani give the longest free resizing, up to a year. Whiteflash gives the shortest window, 10 days, for its lab-grown diamonds.
In short:
The table sets each jeweler's stated terms side by side. "Not captured" means the page we read did not say, and we have not guessed. Where a refund or fee was not stated on the page read, the table says so rather than filling it from another source.
| Jeweler | Return window | Clock starts | Return shipping | Limit on returns | Free resize |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brilliant Earth | 30 days | when the order is available for shipment or pickup | free | none stated | one free resize within 60 days at any size, or up to 1 year if within its recommended range |
| Blue Nile | 30 days | from the shipment date | free insured US label | two complimentary returns per customer per year | one free resize within 6 months, up or down two sizes; shipping is the purchaser's cost |
| Clean Origin | 60 days | the day the order is ready for delivery or pickup | Clean Origin pays; free labels US only | none stated | one free resize within 60 days of the original shipment date (US, standard styles), free shipping both ways |
| Ritani | 30 days | not captured | free within the US, with insurance | two returns or exchanges per customer per year | once free within the first year (FAQ), but its engagement ring page says within 30 days |
| Whiteflash (lab-grown) | 10 days | not captured | not stated on the page read | none stated | not stated on the page read |
| Whiteflash (branded natural) | 30 days | not captured | not stated on the page read | none stated | not stated on the page read |
Not on delivery, for the pages that say. Brilliant Earth's page says its 30 days run from when the order is available for shipment or pickup. Clean Origin says its 60 days begin the day the order is ready for delivery or pickup. Blue Nile counts 30 days from the shipment date. If an order spends days between ready-to-ship and your door, those days come out of the window.
From 30 days to a year, and it is one resize in every case. Blue Nile allows one free resize within 6 months, up or down two sizes, and says the shipping is the purchaser's cost, according to its resizing page. Clean Origin offers one within 60 days of the original shipment date for US customers on standard styles, and says the offer is void if another jeweler has resized or altered the ring, per its resizing page. Brilliant Earth offers one free resize within 60 days at any size, or up to a year if the size is inside its recommended range, and says resized rings cannot be returned.
The same few things, in different words. Brilliant Earth's page excludes engraved, personalized and custom jewelry, rings that have been resized or modified, and Lifetime Diamond Upgrade Program purchases, which it calls final sale; it charges $40 to remove an engraving on a returned ring. Blue Nile's page excludes personalized jewelry, custom orders, engraved items, upgrade purchases and clearance items. Clean Origin treats exchanged or resized orders as final sale, returns custom orders as store credit only, and states a $100 certificate replacement fee and a possible $150 restocking fee if the return code or packaging requirements are missed. Whiteflash's page says custom or altered jewelry is not returnable, with normal sizing excepted.
Screenshot the return and resize page on the day you order, and note the date. Three of the five jewelers start the clock before delivery, and two do not say when it starts. If you buy loose lab-grown stones at Whiteflash, the window is 10 days, so book any independent appraisal inside it.
Choosing the stone first? See how Brilliant Earth's Super Ideal label relates to an IGI report and the lab-grown price basket across jewelers. For the FTC wording that governs terms such as "lab-grown" and "brilliant", see 16 CFR Part 23.
On 23 October 2026 we read each jeweler's own return, resizing or FAQ page and copied the stated numbers, not summaries from review sites. Brilliant Earth, Blue Nile and Whiteflash pages were read by fetching the page text; Clean Origin and Ritani block automated fetches, so their pages were read in a normal browser. Where a page did not state a fact, we say so. We have not placed orders or used any policy, and policies change, so check the live page before you buy. Next review: January 2027.
Clean Origin's own return page, read 23 October 2026, states a 60-day return window starting the day the order is ready for delivery or pickup, with return shipping paid by Clean Origin for US orders. Custom orders can be returned for store credit only, and exchanged or resized orders are final sale.
Blue Nile's returns page states 30 days from the shipment date, with a complimentary insured US label and two complimentary returns per customer per year. Personalized, custom, engraved and Diamond Upgrade Program items are excluded.
Yes, once. Its page says one complimentary resize within 60 days at any size, or up to one year if the size is inside its recommended range, with free shipping both ways. Resized rings are excluded from returns.
On 23 October 2026 its FAQ gave 30 days for its branded natural diamonds and regular catalogue items, and 10 days for lab-grown diamonds, other non-branded natural diamonds and non-catalogue items.
Its pages disagree. Its FAQ says engagement and wedding rings, excluding eternity bands and alternative metals, may be resized once for free within the first year; its engagement ring page says complimentary resizing within 30 days of purchase. Ask Ritani which applies before you rely on either.
Of the three pages that state a start, none says delivery. Brilliant Earth counts from when the order is available for shipment or pickup, Clean Origin from the day it is ready for delivery or pickup, and Blue Nile from the shipment date.